Regulatory PathRegulatory requirements compared

SFDA item 32 · II. Quality changes · II.2 Finished product c) Control of excipients

Change in test procedure for an excipient

Variation category under SFDA, EU and US FDA rules for this change, with the variant wording as published.

Open in the Variation Compass

SFDA Saudi Food and Drug Authority

Guidelines for Variation Requirements v6.3 (DS-G-006), item 32 — official PDF, p. 43 ↗

VariantChangeType
aMinor changes to an approved test procedureType IA
bChange (including replacement or addition) to a biological/immunological/immunochemical test method or a method using a biological reagentType II
cOther changes to a test procedure (including replacement or addition)Type IB
dDeletion of a test procedure if an alternative test procedure is already authorizedType IA

Conditions to be fulfilled and documentation to be supplied: see the official guideline, item 32.

EU European Union

Commission Guidelines C/2025/5045 — EUR-Lex ↗

Q.II.c.2 · Change in analytical procedure for an excipient

VariantChangeType
aMinor change to an approved analytical procedureType IA
bDeletion of an analytical procedure if an alternative analytical procedure is already authorisedType IA
cIntroduction, replacement or substantial change to a biological/immunological/immunochemical analytical procedure for an excipientType II
dOther changes to an analytical procedure (including replacement or addition)Type IB

US FDA US Food and Drug Administration

21 CFR 314.70 and FDA guidance — 2004 Guidance §VIII.B.5–6, §VIII.C.2.b · 2014 AR Guidance App. A 4.3 · 21 CFR 314.70(d)(2)(vii)

ChangeCategoryReference
Minor edit keeping the original methodology, equivalent or better assurance, criteria unchanged (e.g., HPLC flow rate)Annual report2014 App. A 4.3
Add, revise or delete an alternative procedure giving the same or increased assuranceAnnual report21 CFR 314.70(d)(2)(vii)
Other change or replacement of a component test procedure giving the same or increased assuranceCBE-0 supplement2004 §VIII.C.2.b
Change giving reduced assurance (e.g., HPLC no longer resolving impurities), incl. virus/adventitious-agent tests on raw materialsPrior approval supplement2004 §VIII.B.5–6

Note: Biological or bioassay methods for excipients have no NDA-specific rule: the same-or-increased-assurance test decides CBE-0 vs PAS, and reduced-assurance changes to virus/adventitious-agent testing of raw materials are PAS (§VIII.B.6). BLA products follow 21 CFR 601.12.

Other items in II.2 Finished product c) Control of excipients

Not regulatory advice. The binding text is each regulator's current official document; confirm the category with the authority before filing. FDA publishes no classification table: the US category follows FDA guidance or, where the guidance does not name the change, the closest example under 21 CFR 314.70.